Achieve your housing goals

Case Study: How One Agent Turned a Stubborn FSBO Into a Win-Win Deal (Without Lifting a Finger)

When Traditional Real Estate Hits a Wall, Creative Solutions Open Doors

Stuart, a seasoned local real estate agent in Thomson, had a problem many agents face: a motivated seller who simply wouldn’t budge on their stance. No listing agreement. No commission. Just a firm “For Sale By Owner” sign and a determination to go it alone.

Most agents would’ve walked away. Stuart saw an opportunity—not for himself, but for his client.

The Challenge: A Seller Who Refused to Work the Traditional Way

The situation seemed like a dead end. The homeowner was adamant:

  • No listing agreement
  • Unwilling to pay agent commissions
  • Determined to sell the property themselves
  • Needed to sell but wasn’t willing to work within traditional real estate frameworks

For the typical agent, this represents lost time and a dead lead. But Stuart understood something crucial: sometimes the best service you can provide is connecting people with the right solution, even if it’s not the one you offer.

The Solution: A Direct Connection That Changed Everything

Instead of viewing the situation as a loss, Stuart made a strategic decision. He contacted Demargo at Myers House Buyers and made an introduction.

“I don’t need a listing,” Stuart told the seller, “but let me connect you directly with someone who can help.”

This single phone call set off a chain of events that would benefit everyone involved:

For the Seller:

  • No repairs needed
  • No commission payments required
  • No waiting for traditional buyer financing
  • Quick, straightforward cash offer
  • Closed on their timeline without the hassle of showings, open houses, or extended negotiations

The Process: With Stuart’s approval, Demargo contacted the homeowner directly. Unlike a traditional sale that requires:

  • Professional photography
  • Multiple showings and open houses
  • Weeks or months on the market
  • Uncertain buyer financing
  • Potential repair negotiations

Myers House Buyers provided a streamlined alternative. They came to an agreement on price that worked for the seller’s specific situation, and the deal moved forward efficiently.

The Unexpected Win: Everyone Walked Away Happy

Here’s where the story gets better.

Even though the seller maintained they wouldn’t pay Stuart a commission—and Stuart had genuinely said he was fine with that—Myers House Buyers did something remarkable. They paid Stuart a 3% commission directly out of their own proceeds.

Stuart’s Final Tally:

  • ✅ No marketing expenses
  • ✅ No photography costs
  • ✅ No listing preparation work
  • ✅ No showings or open houses
  • ✅ No contract negotiations
  • ✅ Still earned a full 3% commission

The seller got the no-commission, straightforward sale they wanted. Stuart got compensated for his referral and relationship-building. And Myers House Buyers added another satisfied client to their growing portfolio.

Why This Approach Works: Understanding the Motivated Seller

Not every homeowner fits into the traditional real estate model, and that’s okay. Some sellers face circumstances that make conventional listings impractical or impossible:

  • Time constraints: Job relocations, financial pressures, or family situations that require quick action
  • Property condition: Homes needing extensive repairs that sellers can’t afford or don’t want to manage
  • Distressed situations: Inheritance properties, divorce, foreclosure prevention
  • Desire for simplicity: Homeowners who value certainty and speed over maximum dollar value

Myers House Buyers specializes in these exact scenarios. Their cash-buying model eliminates the uncertainties that plague traditional sales:

  • No buyer financing contingencies that fall through
  • No inspection-related repair negotiations
  • No extended closing timelines
  • No commission fees eating into proceeds
  • No requirement to fix, clean, or stage the property

Real Results: What Sellers Are Saying

Cleveland Kelly, who sold his property on Chime Bell Church Road to Myers House Buyers, summed up the experience:

“I am thoroughly pleased with the service from Paul Myers company, and I’d recommend them to anyone. I’d suggest if you have a home that you want to sell, they’d be a good company to go with.”

This kind of feedback isn’t accidental. It comes from a business model built on:

  1. Honest Communication: No games, no gimmicks—just straightforward conversations about what’s possible
  2. Fair Offers: Prices that reflect the property’s true condition and the value of convenience
  3. Flexible Solutions: Working with sellers’ specific timelines and situations
  4. Professional Follow-Through: Delivering on commitments without surprises at closing

The Bigger Picture: Collaboration Over Competition

Perhaps the most important lesson from Stuart’s experience is the power of collaboration. As Paul Myers from Myers House Buyers notes:

“Some agents mistakenly think I’m competition. Why? I’m not sure. I haven’t had listings, and I haven’t represented a single buyer. Instead of thinking competitively, be like Stuart and think collaboratively!”

This philosophy creates opportunities where others see obstacles. When an agent encounters:

  • A FSBO who won’t sign a listing agreement
  • A property in such poor condition that traditional listing isn’t viable
  • A seller who needs to close in days, not months
  • An inherited property where heirs just want a simple, quick sale

These aren’t dead leads—they’re opportunities for connection. Myers House Buyers serves as a resource for agents who want to help clients even when a traditional listing isn’t in the cards.

Your Home, Your Timeline, Your Terms

If you’re facing a situation where traditional real estate feels like the wrong fit, you’re not alone. Whether you’re dealing with:

  • A home that needs more repairs than you can manage
  • A timeline that won’t accommodate months on the market
  • A desire to avoid commissions, showings, and uncertainty
  • Complex family or financial circumstances
  • Simply wanting the simplest, fastest path to “sold”

Myers House Buyers offers a different approach. No obligation. No pressure. Just an honest conversation about your property and your situation, followed by a fair cash offer if it makes sense for both parties.

Sometimes the best solution isn’t the traditional one—it’s the one that actually works for your unique circumstances.

Ready to Explore Your Options?

Paul Myers and the team at Myers House Buyers would be honored to discuss your situation. Whether you’re a homeowner exploring alternatives to traditional listing or an agent with a client facing unique challenges, one conversation could open doors you didn’t know existed.

Contact Myers House Buyers today at 706-294-7343 to start a no-pressure conversation about your property and possibilities.

How One Agent Turned a Stubborn FSBO Into a Win-Win Deal
Myers House Buyers, LLC. BBB Business Review